Despite this increase in female adultery, it is in some degree due to the attitudes changing toward sex and sexuality, but Steinbock thinks that people should use rational justification to evaluate the disapproval of adultery. First, Steinbock makes her essay strong by transparently stating that adultery contradicts moral principles because it involves promise-breaking and lying. In the other words, a promise of sexual fidelity is pertaining to sex and romantic love. Since the moral principles are obeyed and believed by most people in our society, adultery should be banned, unacceptable, and thought to be immoral in most cases.
More Essay Examples on Marriage Rubric A broken promise by one person to be faithful to another is a basic violation of trust. In the other words, a promise of sexual fidelity is pertaining to sex and romantic love.
Since the moral principles are obeyed and believed by most people in our society, adultery should be banned, unacceptable, and thought to be immoral in most cases. Steinbock argues against adultery through a moral approach which meets the mainstream values of our society and should be considered as a strong part of her essay.
In addition, besides talking about the strong part of her essay, the weak parts of her essay should also be reviewed.
Hence, adultery is not banned universally because adultery is a private matter.
Here, Steinbock commits the fallacy of equivocation which means a word shifts from its meaning from one premise to another. The word adultery shifts its meaning from a criminal offense to a private matter in the same argument.
Such a change of meaning always makes an argument invalid and makes the argument unbelievable. Additionally, in the same section, Steinbock denies that practical considerations such as unwanted pregnancies and venereal disease can be used against adultery because not only does adultery face the risk of unwanted pregnancies and venereal disease, but it will also include all non-exclusive sex.
This argument is also invalid because the premise does not intend to support its conclusion. Stating the risks adultery and non-exclusive sex will all face does not prove that the risks themselves are not harmful and cannot be used against adultery.
On the contrary, for example, venereal diseases are serious illnesses that require treatment. Some venereal diseases such as HIV cannot be cured and may be deadly. Therefore, if Steinbock wants to prove that the risks such as venereal disease are not reasons for opposing adultery, she needs to provide more reasonable evidence to support her conclusion.
Otherwise, it will be difficult to make readers believe what she has written.
Then the lack of concern and the desire to cause pain will lead to a lack of love. The fallacy of slippery slope is clearly presented here. Although sexual infidelity may to some degree to be a sign of the lack of love, there is no good reason to think that committing sexual infidelity will actually and finally result in the lack of love.
For instance, a married female sex worker may still love her spouse. She sells sex which is mainly due to a financial issue. She makes money by selling sex to support her family and her spouse.Steinbock/What’s Wrong with Adultery? Adultery is a horrible sin to commit, but it can actually be avoided, although many people in today's society respond differently based on their religion and culture.
Wasserstrom, Steinbock, and Martin on Adultery Richard Wasserstrom Let’s just deﬁne ‘adultery’ to refer to having sex with somebody other than one’s spouse (given that you are in a marriage). Wasserstrom considers an argument for the conclusion that adultery is wrong because it involves breaking promises.
is and in to a was not you i of it the be he his but for are this that by on at they with which she or from had we will have an what been one if would who has her. “Love hurts”—as the saying goes—and a certain amount of pain and difficulty in intimate relationships is unavoidable.
Sometimes it may even be beneficial, since adversity can lead to personal growth, self-discovery, and a range of other components of a life urbanagricultureinitiative.com other . What is wrong with adultery. Evaluating Adultery.
Bonnie Steinbock in her essay “What’s Wrong with Adultery?” starts by quoting the data from studies to show that the number of women who have committed adultery has significantly increased. Reading 1 From Bonnie Steinbock’s () “Adultery” of adultery, men have always done it, and women are catching up.
In any event, they offer merely pragmatic, as opposed to moral, objections. If adultery is wrong, it does not become.